Today’s blog post is written by Pastor Jen.
Last week Friday evening, I was watching the Olympics opening ceremony.
And I was on a text thread with my sister and a friend and colleague of hers, reacting to the different parts of the artistic program as they happened.
My sister, who had watched the program live, as it was broadcast here in the states that afternoon, was telling us about different parts of it and anticipating our reactions.
When we got to one part, featuring a cast of characters in bright costumes arrayed behind a long table, she texted and said: Jen, at this part, I wondered…last supper??
“Yes!” I said, taking in the image.
And we talked a bit about how the central figure looked like a woman, and also appeared to be spinning records – a DJ?
Someone else quoted Ariana Grande lyrics as a joke, and we all moved on.
But the internet did not move on.
Days later, my Facebook thread was exploding with reactions from fellow pastors and theologians who all had something to say about this scene from the ceremonies.
And I had to dig a bit to realize that their reactions were to other reactions, from people loudly decrying the moment as an insult to Christianity, disrespectful, and abhorrent.
As the days went by, the furor only kept mounting, with more people weighing in, either escalating their rhetoric, or in a few cases, pausing to ask good questions:
Why are people so fixated on this?
Why aren’t they showing the same level of anger about the shooting death of Sonya Massey, an elderly black woman killed by police in Springfield, Illinois? Why are they more concerned about this “insult to Christianity” than that – the senseless loss of life of one of God’s children?
Why does this matter so much more?
The designer of the artistic program finally weighed in, assuring people that the scene was meant to depict the bacchanalia, a feast honoring Bacchus, the god of wine (also known as Dionysus) – not Jesus and his disciples.
Art historians examined images of the moment, counted the participants, and concluded that for a variety of reasons it was probably not meant to illustrate the Last Supper – but more likely served as an homage to a 17th century painting by Jan van Biljert called “The Feast of the Gods” (see this NYT article).
But people were shouting too loud to listen by that point, and this morning a friend shared with me news that the Olympic Committee had issued an official apology about the whole thing.
At which point I threw up my hands and sighed.
Not because I don’t like people getting angry. I love when Jesus flips tables in the temple courts, and I recognize the need for righteous anger that makes things better.
But I can’t stand when Christians center themselves so much as to demand respect instead of earn it.
When they get angry about what I would consider the wrong things.
I keep returning to those moments in scripture when Jesus tells his disciples, “if they persecuted me, they will persecute you” and trying to imagine his reaction to this: Christ-followers making a huge scene about a perceived slight.
I keep asking: are we so insecure that we can’t take even the suggestion of a joke? It seems clear enough to me that this wasn’t the intent of that moment in the opening ceremony, but I keep returning to this idea: so what if it was?
Shouldn’t we be able to listen for the criticism implicit in a moment like that, and learn what has been so damaging about our witness that people are driven to make jokes at our expense and throw barbs our way?
Or are we so concerned with preserving our respectability and reputation that we have to yell this loudly at what we think is an insult – even when it’s not?
I don’t know about you, but to me, this doesn’t seem to embody Jesus’ way.
As a friend and colleague said to me over lunch today, I think Jesus would have been more likely to sit down at that table than to yell at the people already there.
One article I read about this firestorm of reactions called it “a ridiculous moral panic.”
And I honestly have to agree. It seems both clear to me that we weren’t the butt of a joke, and that even if we were, that’s more a cause for reflection and conversation than indignation and outrage.
But I keep coming back to a point that others have made, and more eloquently than I will here:
Pay attention to what people are mad about.
Watch where they put their energy into making things “right.”
Is it the suffering of vulnerable people?
Is it the protection of marginalized communities?
Or is it their reputation? Their own rights? Their privileges and opportunities?
I don’t know that there’s one lesson to be learned from all this; I suspect there are many.
But I encourage you to think about this, whether in regards to the Olympics, or the next time you feel affronted: why am I angry? What am I trying to protect?
Maybe you’ll learn something. Maybe you’ll still have to yell a little bit, but then again maybe not.
Maybe you’ll create the space for a more Christ-like response.
Maybe you’ll realize, as I keep doing, that Jesus doesn’t need us to defend him, but to follow him.
Most of all, that is my hope.
Yours,
Pastor Jen